Graphics: 10/10

For late X-box Gen graphics this was one of the top cuts. Not only were the cutscenes good but the game's enviroment was nice. The little details like birds, warefalls, fires, and rubble make the game.

Campaign: 7/10

Its like Halo but the "Empire Strikes Back" HAHAHA now you HAVE to play Halo 3 attitude made this a segway game, not as much a standalone.

FunFactor: 10/10

The multiplayer is still great and really utilized X-Box live, well as much as an XBox game did.

Replayability: 8/10

?I can't survive on multiplayer alone. The campaign's battles are predictable on your 4th-5th play through of a mission.

Difficulty: 10/10

I don't mean its insanely difficult when I say 10/10. I mean that it can be tuned. Easy is easy, and Legendary is difficult. The way games should be made you can build up and each level is just that nesecary bit harder.

Innovation: 8/10

I've played this game before, but they did a great job of adding nice things. Namely the sword, which has become a favorite to everyone. And the addition of two new races. Good job for a great predecessor.

?Personal notes: I love the new customization too. Its one of the few games that had options like this at the time.

Overall: 9/10